Selling Preowned Tiffany Jewelry: A Practical Guide

If you are considering selling Tiffany jewelry, identify the design and gather the records you have before requesting an offer. The jewelry photos retained here are general illustrations; they do not establish that the pictured pieces were made by Tiffany & Co.

Identify the piece as precisely as possible

Record the collection or design name if known, metal, size and any visible markings. Matching earrings, necklace length, bracelet size and ring size help a buyer understand the piece. Do not guess a collection name from a similar online photo.

Use paperwork as supporting evidence

Receipts, service records and original packaging can help tell the piece's history. A blue box, hallmark or familiar shape alone does not establish authenticity. The jewelry itself needs examination, and any uncertainty should be discussed before an offer is finalized.

Tell the buyer about resizing, repairs, engraving or replaced components. If you do not know the history, simply say that it is unknown.

Compare offers for the finished piece

A signed design may be evaluated differently from generic jewelry of the same metal weight. Condition, completeness and current demand still matter. Online asking prices can provide context but are not proof of completed sales or of what a buyer will pay you.

Ask whether the offer includes all stones and components and whether any charges would reduce the amount you receive.

Decide how much time you have

A direct sale and consignment have different payment timelines and responsibilities. If you choose consignment, obtain the fee, price approval and return terms in writing.

Arrange an evaluation at our Boca Raton showroom and bring the piece with its supporting records. You can compare the offer with your reasons for selling without treating a brand name as a promise of profit.